AL
SS - Jason Bartlett .373 batting average, 1.014 On base Plus Slugging percentage
1B - Kevin Youkilis .353 BA, 1.101 OPS
2B - Ian Kinsler .269 BA, .886 OPS
C - Joe Mauer .415 BA, 1.277 OPS
3B - Evan Longoria .313 BA, .988 OPS
OF - Nelson Cruz .287 BA, .947 OPS
OF - Torii Hunter .313 BA, .968 OPS
OF - Adam Jones .340 BA, .974 OPS
NL
1B - Albert Pujols .320 BA, 1.095 OPS
2B - Chase Utley .295 BA, .993 OPS
SS - Hanley Ramirez .326 BA, .920 OPS
3B - Ryan Zimmerman .323 BA, .932 OPS
OF - Justin Upton .313 BA, .974 OPS
OF - Carlos Beltran .342 BA, 1.003 OPS
OF - Mike Cameron .272 BA, .900 OPS
C - Brian McCann .308 BA, .926 OPS
Right now I'm leaning towards Zach Greinke to start for the AL, and Chris Carpenter in the NL. Also, Jason Verlander and Dan Haren will probably be there as well.